Comments for federalidea.com http://federalidea.com/focus Fri, 15 Aug 2008 13:30:31 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.4 hourly 1 Comment on ‘Against violent oppression, violent resistance is moral’ by Dayan Jayatilleka http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/400/comment-page-1#comment-43582 Dayan Jayatilleka Fri, 15 Aug 2008 13:30:31 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/400#comment-43582 Sri wants to know " Now Dayan wants to tell us about clean guerrilla warfare. Could Dayan tell us a single guerrilla movement that had not adopted terrorist tactics?" That's so easy, man. The Cubans, Nicaraguans (Sandinitsas), Chinese, Vietnamese. Sri wants to know ” Now Dayan wants to tell us about clean guerrilla warfare. Could Dayan tell us a single guerrilla movement that had not adopted terrorist tactics?”

That’s so easy, man. The Cubans, Nicaraguans (Sandinitsas), Chinese, Vietnamese.

]]>
Comment on Mahavamsa Myths About Leonine Ancestry Of Sinhala People by sunimal http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/76/comment-page-2#comment-18020 sunimal Mon, 09 Jun 2008 05:46:22 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/76#comment-18020 Interesting. Not even one of the comments above by a sinhalese insists that the Mahawansa is the literal truth, but agree that it has some mythical elements. But a significant no of tamils writing in have a distorted and unverified interpretation of their own history. What does that say doc Lankasathuru Interesting.

Not even one of the comments above by a sinhalese insists that the Mahawansa is the literal truth, but agree that it has some mythical elements.

But a significant no of tamils writing in have a distorted and unverified interpretation of their own history.

What does that say doc Lankasathuru

]]>
Comment on Gota lays down his law to journos by Saravanaraj http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463/comment-page-1#comment-17344 Saravanaraj Fri, 06 Jun 2008 16:20:41 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463#comment-17344 Oh Yes, East has been captured from enamy (as it is belongs to someone else) and handover to another !!!! Oh Yes, East has been captured from enamy (as it is belongs to someone else) and handover to another !!!!

]]>
Comment on Sri Lanka, Somalia, Islam and the West by S Galpotta http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/464/comment-page-1#comment-17185 S Galpotta Fri, 06 Jun 2008 04:11:01 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/464#comment-17185 On what basis an indivdual is labled as a muslim, christian, buddhist or of any other religion. Who can certify without any doubt that such individual is of such religion ? Indivdul's behaviour, attitudes and way of thinking which may decide his or her religion is not visible at all. Onthe the other hand these factors are subject to change continuesly due to changes in his environment on continues basis. On this ground it is meaningless to lable a country as a muslim, christian or buddhist country. It is meaningless to fight for religious rights when the individul's religion is questionable and subject to change continuesly. On what basis an indivdual is labled as a muslim, christian, buddhist or of any other religion. Who can certify without any doubt that such individual is of such religion ?

Indivdul’s behaviour, attitudes and way of thinking which may decide his or her religion is not visible at all. Onthe the other hand these factors are subject to change continuesly due to changes in his environment on continues basis.

On this ground it is meaningless to lable a country as a muslim, christian or buddhist country.

It is meaningless to fight for religious rights when the individul’s religion is questionable and subject to change continuesly.

]]>
Comment on Gota lays down his law to journos by Devinda Fernando http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463/comment-page-1#comment-17083 Devinda Fernando Thu, 05 Jun 2008 19:12:35 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463#comment-17083 *** Gota and his government are losing the war against the LTTE. *** No they are not Sarvan, You obviously have not been keeping up with the facts on the ground. East has been captured, Army is making steady progress into the North. Just a matter of time *** Gota and his government are losing the war against the LTTE. ***

No they are not Sarvan,

You obviously have not been keeping up with the facts on the ground. East has been captured, Army is making steady progress into the North. Just a matter of time

]]>
Comment on Gota lays down his law to journos by Sarvan http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463/comment-page-1#comment-17043 Sarvan Thu, 05 Jun 2008 15:50:19 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463#comment-17043 Gota and his government are losing the war against the LTTE. The only way to prevent the truth of soldier casualities and weapons lost to the LTTE would be to threaten journos. He is just doing that. He fails to know what the international mass media are capable of doing !! Gota and his government are losing the war against the LTTE. The only way to prevent the truth of soldier casualities and weapons lost to the LTTE would be to threaten journos.

He is just doing that. He fails to know what the international mass media are capable of doing !!

]]>
Comment on Sri Lanka, Somalia, Islam and the West by ilaya seran senguttuvan http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/464/comment-page-1#comment-16966 ilaya seran senguttuvan Thu, 05 Jun 2008 11:05:17 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/464#comment-16966 Islam preached today is not as simple as in the case of the Mufti mentioned here. Unlike the Islam of - let's say - the previous 50s today's Islam is violent in most cases and lacks tolerance. Bin Laden himself makes it clear "those who do not practise the Islam we do are traitors and should be killed." The Borahs of the world today - a peaceful Islamic sect - chose to come to violence-prone Colombo to hold their Annual Conferences although they are in larger numbers in Mumbai and other parts of India, Pakistan and East Africa. Their last 2 Conferences were held in Colombo and most Sri Lankans, including the Govt, do not know why but pat themselves on the back re-assuring themselves Sri Lanka is still considered a safe place at least by some. Borahs wanted to hold their last Confab in Mumbai but at the last moment changed it to Colombo because other Muslim radicals were said to be planning to violently disturb the Confab if held in Mumbai. Until Saddam came along Sunnis and Shiaites lived in relative peace in Iraq. I am told inter-marriages between them were common there but Saddam ruined the equilibrium and the blood-letting continues. Lebanon is ruined by intra-Muslim local war-fare. The Wahabis are in hiding everywhere - although they are Muslims. When Christiane Amanpour did her week-long Programme on Christianity, Judaism and Islam a few months ago the Egyptian Islamic clerics were clear there "the Islamic-Christian war fare now on will have to be fought to the finish" Personally, I see the Islamics who see "tomorrow belongs to us" (read Naipaul) will not rest until the world sees more bloodshed. The Americans have no intention of allowing the attackers of 9/11 go un-punished. Iraq was the first they went after. Even Barak in his speech at AIPAC yesterday at Washington made it clear he will go after the Iranians and Al Quida/Osama Bin Laden. His Statement Jerusalem belongs to the Israelis will be resisted and the Islamic world (including strong American allies like the Saudis) will have to take a position against the Americans. I am afraid the peaceful Islam and adherents we knew in our days have been hijacked by the extremist Muslims brain-washed by the growing madrasas world-wide. Islam preached today is not as simple as in the case of the Mufti mentioned here. Unlike the Islam of – let’s say – the previous 50s today’s Islam is violent in most cases and lacks tolerance.

Bin Laden himself makes it clear “those who do not practise the Islam we do are traitors and should be killed.” The Borahs of the world today – a peaceful Islamic sect – chose to come to violence-prone Colombo to hold their Annual Conferences although they are in larger numbers in Mumbai and other parts of India, Pakistan and East Africa. Their last 2 Conferences were held in Colombo and most Sri Lankans, including the Govt, do not know why but pat themselves on the back re-assuring themselves Sri Lanka is still considered a safe place at least by some. Borahs wanted to hold their last Confab in Mumbai but at the last moment changed it to Colombo because other Muslim radicals were said to be planning to violently disturb the Confab if held in Mumbai. Until Saddam came along Sunnis and Shiaites lived in relative peace in Iraq. I am told inter-marriages between them were common there but Saddam ruined the equilibrium and the blood-letting continues.

Lebanon is ruined by intra-Muslim local war-fare. The Wahabis are in hiding everywhere – although they are Muslims. When Christiane Amanpour did her week-long Programme on Christianity, Judaism and Islam a few months ago the Egyptian Islamic clerics were clear there “the Islamic-Christian war fare now on will have to be fought to the finish”

Personally, I see the Islamics who see “tomorrow belongs to us” (read Naipaul) will not rest until the world sees more bloodshed. The Americans have no intention of allowing the attackers of 9/11 go un-punished. Iraq was the first they went after. Even Barak in his speech at AIPAC yesterday at Washington made it clear he will go after the Iranians and Al Quida/Osama Bin Laden. His Statement Jerusalem belongs to the Israelis will be resisted and the Islamic world (including strong American allies like the Saudis) will have to take a position against the Americans. I am afraid the peaceful Islam and adherents we knew in our days have been hijacked by the extremist Muslims brain-washed by the growing madrasas
world-wide.

]]>
Comment on Gota lays down his law to journos by Devinda Fernando http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463/comment-page-1#comment-16749 Devinda Fernando Wed, 04 Jun 2008 17:33:21 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463#comment-16749 Journalists these days no longer report the news. They have Political Agendas. The "Military Matters Column" injecting Personal Opinion into the mix. Now it has just become another Opinion Column by someone who does not like The Rajapakse Government's prosecution of the war. I have no sympathy. Journalists these days no longer report the news. They have Political Agendas.

The “Military Matters Column” injecting Personal Opinion into the mix. Now it has just become another Opinion Column by someone who does not like The Rajapakse Government’s prosecution of the war. I have no sympathy.

]]>
Comment on Strengthening the Provincial Council Process by Sarath http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/462/comment-page-1#comment-16312 Sarath Tue, 03 Jun 2008 10:38:07 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/462#comment-16312 "What are the safeguards to prevent these problems whch are endemic to Srilanka. " They are not endemic to Sri Lanka. Look at India. Everything might look fine and dandy on the surface but scratch a little and the divisions are immense. For example, go to the Rediff website and pick a news article and look at the comments below the article - you'll find people from different ethnic groups from their ethnic states fight each other, call each other names and act like total bigots. That's what Sri Lanka is going to be like if devolution on an ethnic basis takes place. “What are the safeguards to prevent these problems whch are endemic to Srilanka. ”

They are not endemic to Sri Lanka. Look at India. Everything might look fine and dandy on the surface but scratch a little and the divisions are immense. For example, go to the Rediff website and pick a news article and look at the comments below the article – you’ll find people from different ethnic groups from their ethnic states fight each other, call each other names and act like total bigots. That’s what Sri Lanka is going to be like if devolution on an ethnic basis takes place.

]]>
Comment on Gota lays down his law to journos by sn rajah http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463/comment-page-1#comment-15946 sn rajah Mon, 02 Jun 2008 13:02:09 +0000 http://federalidea.com/focus/archives/463#comment-15946 The people of this country had great respect for Secretary Rajapaksa for his effort to crackdown on the LTTE and were aghast when he faced an LTTE suicide attack at the Pithala junction Colombo sometime ago!!!!!!! Really? Do they? The people of this country had great respect for Secretary Rajapaksa for his effort to crackdown on the LTTE and were aghast when he faced an LTTE suicide attack at the Pithala junction Colombo sometime ago!!!!!!!

Really? Do they?

]]>